"Buy One Get One" lyrics

You said you'd never love again
'Til the sky falls
You put a hole in my heart
And I put one in the drywall
When I heard that you were out with him
Word sure gets around
But I'm still staring at the clouds
Waiting for it all to fall down

But this ain't buy one, get one free
If you're still in love with him, you can't have me
You can't have one foot in the past
And one foot in the dark
No, you're tearing me apart
You're tearing me apart

I said I'd never let you go
'Til the stars burn out
It burnt a hole in my soul
And now I'm still trying to figure it out
When I heard that you were holding him
The silence spokes so loud
But you keep stringing me along
In case you and him don't work it out

But this ain't buy one, get one free
If you're still in love with him, you can't have me
You can't have one foot in the past
And one foot in the dark
No, you're tearing me apart
You're tearing me apart

I gave you everything I had
But you left me in the cold
And now I'm standing here alone
Letting go of the only love I know
But I keep waiting for a sign
Tired of waiting for you to decide
You keep coming back for more
As you're walking out the door

But this ain't buy one, get one free
If you're still in love with him, you can't have me
You can't have one foot in the past
And one foot in the dark
No, you're tearing me apart
You're tearing me apart