"Not That Simple" lyrics

When we first met, I was just a sophomore
We spent the night on Lydia's couch
I didn't know you were gonna break my heart then
I didn't know the pain I'd feel right now
And I smile, yes I smile
But underneath are memories
That I'm trying, yeah, I'm trying
To let go

But it's not that simple
Type of misery
All these mixed up signals
In my head
I still hear these echoes
Of when you loved me
But now you're just someone in my mind
That used to be mine

People used to say I didn't deserve you
I was cool with that, 'cause I felt the same
But then they played my song on the radio
And I don't think you liked who I became
And so you left, yeah, you left
On someone else's arm now
And I'm trying, yeah, I'm trying to let go

But it's not that simple
Type of misery
All these mixed up signals
In my head
I still hear these echoes
Of when you loved me
But now you're just someone in my mind
That used to be mine

'Cause baby, your beauty marks
Are like shooting stars
In my goofy heart is one of Cupid's darts
I'm just a nervous guy
And these words of mine
Won't reverse the time
To when you were mine

'Cause it's not that simple
Type of misery
All these mixed up signals

No, it's not that simple
Type of misery
All these mixed up signals
In my head
I still hear these echoes
Of when you loved me
But now you're just someone in my mind
Now you're just someone in my mind
That used to be mine